Introduction to Targeted Risk Analysis (TRA) in PCI DSS 4.0

PCI DSS TRA featured

The Payment Card Industry Security Standards Council (PCI SSC) recently released a new document guiding targeted risk analysis. This approach to security is a cornerstone of the PCI DSS 4.0 update, and yet, for many businesses, this is something new that they may need help understanding. 

This article will discuss Targeted Risk Analysis, its role in PCI DSS 4.0, and how your organization can consider implementing these measures as part of their compliance efforts.


Overview of PCI DSS 4.0 and the Introduction of TRA

PCI DSS version 4.0 has introduced a significant update in Targeted Risk Analysis. This new element is designed to provide organizations with a more flexible and tailored approach to managing security risks related to cardholder data. 

The primary goal of TRA within PCI DSS 4.0 is to enable entities to make informed, risk-based decisions regarding the frequency and methodology of security controls, thereby enhancing the effectiveness of their data security measures.

Instead of a one-size-fits-all model, TRA empowers organizations to assess and address risks most pertinent to their specific operational environments. This shift marks a significant evolution in the PCI DSS framework, recognizing the diversity of business models and the varying threats different entities face.


Importance of TRA in the Context of PCI DSS Compliance

The introduction of TRA in PCI DSS 4.0 underscores the importance of a risk-focused approach to security. It acknowledges that threats to cardholder data are not static and that the security landscape is continuously evolving. By implementing TRA, organizations can ensure that their security measures comply with PCI DSS and are effective against current and emerging threats.

Understanding the Two Types of TRAs in PCI DSS 4.0

  • Type 1 (TRA for Defining Activity Frequency): One of the critical aspects of TRA in PCI DSS 4.0 is its application in defining how frequently specific security controls should be performed. As specified in PCI DSS Requirement 12.3.1, this type of TRA allows organizations to determine an appropriate control frequency based on a thorough assessment of their unique risk environment. This comprehensive evaluation ensures that the frequency of each security control is aligned with the actual risk profile of the organization.
  • Type 2 (TRA for Customized Approach): The second type of TRA, detailed in Requirement 12.3.2, is used when an organization opts for a customized approach to meet specific PCI DSS requirements. This TRA is vital for entities that implement alternative security measures, providing a structured methodology to demonstrate that these measures offer an equivalent or higher level of protection than the standard PCI DSS requirements.

Organizations can thoroughly assess the risks of not following a defined PCI DSS requirement through this TRA and justify their customized controls. The outcome of this analysis must clearly show how the chosen approach meets the Customized Approach Objective, ensuring that it effectively addresses the intended security goals.


Specific PCI DSS Requirements Involving TRAs

The PCI DSS 4.0 standard has specific requirements that mandate completing a targeted risk analysis to determine the frequency of certain activities. Here’s a breakdown of these requirements and the suggested frequencies:

  • Requirement Defines how often an organization must conduct malware scans as part of their TRA efforts for periodic assessments of components not considered at risk of malware.
  • Requirement Defines periodic reviews of account access by application and system accounts and related privileges to align with risk assessment.
  • Requirement 8.6.3: Defines assessments for changing passwords/passphrases for application and system accounts that should be part of TRA efforts. 
  • Requirement Defines how periodic reviews of Point of Interaction devices are inspected as part of an organization’s risk management and analysis effort. 
  • Requirement Periodic log reviews must be part of an organization’s TRA efforts. 
  • Requirement Organizations must include non-critical or less serious security issues in their TRA reviews, 
  • Requirement 11.6.1: TRA must include assessing and verifying tamper-proof mechanisms to protect payment pages with HTTP headers. 
  • Requirement Periodic training for incident response personnel.


Process and Implementation of TRAs

Conducting a Targeted Risk Analysis (TRA) in the context of PCI DSS 4.0 involves several critical steps. Firstly, entities must identify the specific assets and the threats or outcomes the PCI DSS requirements are designed to protect against. This identification process is crucial for understanding the context and scope of the risk analysis.

The steps necessary to handle TRAs under PCI DSS include:

  • Identify Specific Assets and Threats: Determine which assets, such as log files or credentials, are relevant to the PCI DSS requirements. Identify potential threats or adverse outcomes that the requirements aim to protect against, like malware, unauthorized intruders, or misuse of credentials. 
  • Assess the Likelihood and Impact of Threats: Evaluate the probability of each identified threat occurring and the potential impact if it does. Consider factors increasing the vulnerability of assets (e.g., exposure to untrusted networks, environment complexity, high staff turnover). Consider the criticality of system components and the sensitivity of the data involved.
  • Document the TRA Findings: Record the findings from the identification and assessment phases. Clearly articulate the rationale behind the chosen frequency of security controls or any customized approach adopted. Ensure that all required elements, as per PCI DSS v4.0 Requirement 12.3.1, are included in the documentation.
  • Use Available Resources and Templates: Utilize the Sample Template for TRA provided in the PCI SSC Document Library as a guide. While adherence to the template’s format isn’t mandatory, including all its specified elements is essential for a robust TRA.
  • Review and Update the TRA Annually: Conduct an annual review of the TRA to ensure its findings and conclusions remain relevant and accurate. Update the TRA in response to significant changes in the organization’s environment, evolving threats, trends, or technologies.
  • Prepare for Compliance Assessment: Keep the TRA documentation ready for review by PCI DSS assessors. Ensure that the documentation provides a clear understanding of the risk analysis process, decisions made, and justifications for those decisions. 


The Importance of TRAs in Risk Management and Compliance


As risk analysis becomes a cornerstone of most compliance standards, the more complex assessment, monitoring, and documentation requirements fall onto businesses or their security partners. The benefit of this, however, is that these organizations have a much more proactive and robust security apparatus than those working with ad hoc approaches. 

Targeted risk analysis is therefore essential for several reasons. 

  • Customized Risk Management: TRAs allow entities to tailor their security measures to their unique operational environments, leading to more effective risk management.
  • Informed Decision-Making: By conducting TRAs, entities make well-informed decisions about the frequency and nature of security controls, ensuring they are proportionate to the level of risk
  • Dynamic Response to Threats: TRAs facilitate an active approach to security, enabling organizations to adapt to evolving threats and vulnerabilities.
  • Resource Optimization: TRAs help prioritize resources towards areas of higher risk, optimizing security budgets and efforts.
  • Enhanced Security Awareness: Conducting TRAs raises overall awareness of security within the organization, leading to a culture more attuned to risk management and data protection.

Implement All Your PCI DSS Requirements Effectively with Lazarus Alliance

Working towards PCI DSS 4.0 compliance? Contact our team of experts to work with the only partner you’ll need to maintain your security and compliance infrastructure. 

Lazarus Alliance